‘Whose land is this? Constructing counter-narratives through maps’
By Noreen H. Sapalo
University of the Philippines
In January 2019, my fieldwork for a counter-mapping research project began. Our team was led by Filipino geographers who were experts on counter-mapping methods, with years of experience producing maps with various disadvantaged communities. I, on the other hand, was a mapping neophyte, and the only anthropologist in the team. Imagine the horror: a ‘geographic idiot’ – one with a terrible sense of space and direction — working with a bunch of geographers.
According to Nancy Peluso (1995), counter-mapping is a process where communities appropriate the state’s techniques of formal mapping and make their own maps as alternatives to those used by government. Critical geographers emphasize that embedded in the idea of counter-mapping is the recognition of two important things: that maps are political and ideological apparatuses, and that the act of mapping is an inherently political act. This can be seen in as early as the 15th century, when maps were used by Portugal and Spain to determine and navigate unknown parts of the world, and later on, to claim the land as theirs.
Over the years, the number of counter-mapping efforts across the globe has grown as a response to the rise in number of development aggression projects, or ‘development’ projects that violate the human rights of poor populations. Successful counter-mapping collaborations between critical geographers and indigenous communities caught in land disputes with governments have influenced scholars and grassroots activists in the global south to pursue their own counter-mapping projects in urban and peri-urban areas. In the Philippines, urban poor communities facing threats of demolition and displacement have successfully worked with geographers and architects to make maps that reflect their relationship with the various spaces within their communities. These maps are also reflections of their aspirations and demands.
In the course of the project, our counter-mapping team was able to produce maps with the farmers and indigenous peoples residing in Capas, Tarlac, a town north of Manila. Their communities have been drastically affected by the construction of New Clark City, a 9,500-hectare state-led project lauded as the first “smart, sustainable, and resilient city” in the country. Part of this “smart city” is an Athletics Stadium and Sports Hub which currently serves as venue of the controversial 30th Southeast Asian Games this year. It is feared that these structures will share the same fate as previous Olympics stadiums – left largely unused, ultimately becoming abandoned white elephants.
In just under six months of fieldwork, we saw the extreme and terrifying change of landscape in the affected areas: hundreds of trees were felled, creeks dried, and mountains flattened; this, despite claims from the Philippine government that New Clark City is “environment-friendly.” The promotional materials of the project used the rhetoric of “empty, idle lands” and featured maps and dioramas filled with green spaces, occasionally peppered with eco-friendly buildings and parks, to lure public support and more investments. The stark contrast between their maps and ours was too baffling, it forced a team member to ask: are we really talking about the same space? What is this utopia that they’re mapping? How can they drive away indigenous Aetas and wipe out the rich ecosystems of the area and, in the same breath, claim that they are designing a ‘green’ city?
Now that we have entered the Anthropocene, I realize how counter-mapping can play a crucial role in the engagements that anthropologists and other social scientists have in the field, especially when those engagements are with populations in dire circumstances.
It can be observed that despite the primacy of ‘place’ as one of the most important and defining criterion of a culture, the nature and characteristics of a population’s relationship to that place still remains largely unexamined (Hammond, 2004). Understanding a population’s relationship to a place, how they make sense of the spaces in that place, and their process of ‘emplacement’ is essential to broader questions of resistance and power dynamics. This is where anthropologists come in: aside from helping produce counter-maps, anthropologists can work with communities to construct counter-narratives that are embodied in counter-cartographies, and consequently, that speak truth to power. This is no easy feat, and it is undoubtedly replete with risks. But it has to be done. Admittedly, I follow Ortner (2016) in her appeal to respond to the increasingly harsh conditions of the real world with ‘dark anthropology,’ or an anthropology that “emphasizes the harsh and brutal dimensions of human experience, and the structural and historical conditions that produce them (p. 49).” This entails that in working with disadvantaged populations, it is imperative that we pay greater attention to their method, and their ways of thinking and being. Counter-mapping, after all, acknowledges the use of more than one knowledge base.
Back in March, while walking with an indigenous Aeta woman in her community, she uttered: “Hindi dapat tinatanong kung sino ang may-ari ng lupang ito. Kasi, syempre, sasabihin nila: ‘eh ‘di ang gobyerno,’ talo na kami agad nun. Dapat ang tanong ay: Sino ba ang nag-alaga at nagpaunlad ng lupang ito? Kami. Kami dapat ang tumira dito.” (“The question shouldn’t be ‘who owns this land?,’ because obviously the answer is ‘the Philippine government’ – and we would lose that fight. Instead, the question must be: Who took care of and developed these lands for many years? It is us. We should be the ones to live here.”) Thus, the importance not only of maps produced with communities at the periphery, but also of the rich narratives that come with them.
BCDA, the government agency in charge of New Clark City, razed a farmers’ rice fields, just before harvest.
Hammond, L. 2004. This place will become home, refugee repatriation to Ethiopia. Ithaca and London: Cornell University Press.
Peluso, N. 1995. Whose Whose Woods are These? Counter-mapping Forest Territories in Kalimantan, Indonesia. Antipode 27, 4:383-406.
Its good as your other posts : D, thankyou for putting up.
I keep listening to the newscast lecture about receiving free online grant applications so I have been looking around for the most excellent site to get one. Could you advise me please, where could i get some?
I?¦ve recently started a web site, the information you offer on this website has helped me tremendously. Thank you for all of your time & work.
Awsome post and right to the point. I don’t know if this is truly the best place to ask but do you people have any ideea where to employ some professional writers? Thx 🙂
I’m curious to find out what blog platform you have been using? I’m having some minor security problems with my latest blog and I’d like to find something more safeguarded. Do you have any solutions?
Hello there, I found your blog by the use of Google whilst searching for a related topic, your website came up, it seems great. I have bookmarked it in my google bookmarks.
Çocukluk döneminde sevgi paylaşımı kötü genleri devre dışı bırakır.
4. Aşk, bağımlılıklardan koruyabilir. 5. Sevgi dolu bir ilişki içinde güvende hissetmek, dünyaya daha
çok açılmamızı sağlar. 6. Aşk, bağışıklık sistemini korur.
7. Acı veren duygularla daha kolay başa çıkmanızı sağlar.
4K Porno Amatör Anal Asyalı Bakire & Kızlık Bozma Biseksüel Blowjob Brazzers Seks Erotik Esmer Fake
Taxi Gay porn Genç Grup.
bunadisisj nsjjsjsisjsmizjzjjzjzz zumzsert
Bu arada kızlık zarı zedelenmesinde kan gelmez, sadece
şişlik ve kızarıklık olur, dolayısı ile bakirelik devam eder.
Genel olarak konuşmak gerekirse bir damla kadar az
bile olsa kızlık zarı kanı geldiğinde bekaretin bozulma ihtimali %80 lere çıkar ve bu
durumda ileride gerdek gecesinde kızlık zarı kanaması olmayacaktır.
Attractive section of content. I just stumbled upon your site and in accession capital to assert that I get in fact enjoyed account your blog posts. Anyway I’ll be subscribing to your augment and even I achievement you access consistently rapidly.
Write more, thats all I have to say. Literally, it seems as though you relied on the video to make your point. You definitely know what youre talking about, why throw away your intelligence on just posting videos to your blog when you could be giving us something enlightening to read?
Kızını siken babalar sikiş pornolar. Şebnem henüz 22
yaşındayım çok azdım! beni ilk arayan çok şanslı Telefon Numaram:
43. 00:00. 00:00. Editör: porno. kızını siken baba.
bunadisisj nsjjsjsisjsmizjzjjzjzz zumzsert
En iyi erkegi azdiran kadin turkce konusmali sikiş videoları 7DAK ile, kaliteli sikiş videoları, türkçe izlenme rekoru kıran seks izle.
Ve Kadın Erkeği Yarattı Yayınevi Geoturka Yayınevi Yazar Donna Sozio Barkod Baskı Sayısı
Sayfa Sayısı 244 Cilt Durumu Ciltsiz Amazonda 1 Numara!
Tüm Seks Tüpleri. En iyi. Etiketler:Masaj Turkce underlying massage turkce
Turkce altyazili Natasha nice underlying Altyazili turkce Turkce porn Turkce porn Turkce Sub-Software PornMasaj Turkce underlying massage turkce Turkce
altyazili Natasha nice underlying Altyazili turkce Turkce porn Turkce porn Turkce Sub-Software Porn.
Fahişe türk porno sexs # 29. İki kız. naylon porno)
dört vk hd sex porno ayak) 2 türk seks porno video Danimarka
Oyunu-Maya. Yaşlı dick turk porno sex video.
DirtyStepDaughter İzin Beni hd.
Absolutely written content, Really enjoyed looking at.
This is a topic close to my heart cheers, where are your contact details though?
Some really nice stuff on this internet site, I love it.
Having read this I thought it was really enlightening. I
appreciate you finding the time and effort to put this short article together.
I once again find myself personally spending a lot of time both reading and leaving comments.
But so what, it was still worthwhile!
Here is my webpage – tracfone special coupon 2022
Hello my loved one! I wish to say that this post is amazing, nice written and include approximately all vital infos. I¦d like to look extra posts like this .
มันเพิ่มความตึงเครียดให้กับการแข่งขันฟุตบอลโลกของอาร์เจนตินา ซึ่งเริ่มตึงเครียดเล็กน้อยในวันเสาร์ด้วยการประกาศของปารีส-แซงต์-แชร์กแมงว่าเขาจะได้พักเพื่อเดินทางไปลอริยองต์เนื่องจากอาการบาดเจ็บทำให้ตกใจ“ลีโอ เมสซี่ จะยังคงรักษาเอ็นร้อยหวายอักเสบ เพื่อเป็นการป้องกันไว้ก่อน” สปอร์ตพูล 2 ธันวาคม 2565 แถลงการณ์ของเปแอสเช อ่าน“เขาจะกลับมาฝึกซ้อมร่วมกันในสัปดาห์หน้า”กัปตันและเครื่องรางของขลังชาวอาร์เจนติน่าได้ค้นพบรูปแบบของเขาอีกครั้งในฤดูกาลนี้ก่อนการแข่งขันฟุตบอลโลกซึ่งเริ่มในวันที่ 20 พฤศจิกายนโดยทำประตูได้ 12 ประตูและเพิ่มผู้ช่วย 14 คนในการแข่งขันทั้งหมดสำหรับ PSG หลังจากดิ้นรนกับการย้ายไปเมืองหลวงของฝรั่งเศสเมื่อปีที่แล้ว
Thank you for the good writeup. It in fact was a amusement account it.
Look advanced to more added agreeable from you! By the way,
how could we communicate?
Also visit my homepage: tracfone coupon
This is a topic which is close to my heart… Take care! Where are your contact details though?
Asking questions are actually pleasant thing if you are not understanding something totally, but this piece of writing offers pleasant understanding yet.|
I visited various sites however the audio quality for audio songs present at this web site is genuinely wonderful.|
My website; search engine Optimisation Services
my web-site :: Middletown Mesothelioma Compensation
my web site; klamath falls mesothelioma Settlement
If some one wants expert view regarding blogging and site-building
then i advise him/her to pay a quick visit this webpage, Keep up the fastidious work.
Take a look at my site – electric folding mobility scooter (star123.Kr)
Have a look at my blog post: mesothelioma Claim in Highland
Also visit my webpage; mesothelioma compensation madison Heights
Look into my web blog; Owasso Mesothelioma Law firm
Have a look at my web site :: Mesothelioma Attorney In Dexter
Very quickly this website will be famous among all blog visitors, due to
it’s nice articles
Check out my webpage foldable motorized Scooter (telcorecorp.Com)
I all the time emailed this web site post page to all
my contacts, for the reason that if like to read it afterward my links will too.
my blog Folding mobility Scooters
Stop by my homepage; punxsutawney mesothelioma law firm
Also visit my website – Austin mesothelioma settlement
my blog post mesothelioma attorney highland park
Also visit my web blog: richmond heights Mesothelioma law firm
This is my first time pay a quick visit at here and i am in fact happy to read all at one place.
Here is my website: Fold up Mobility scooter
my blog … Jackson Mesothelioma Lawyer
Here is my blog … barnwell mesothelioma Law firm
My site – Mesothelioma Lawyer Pine Bluff
my web-site … mesothelioma compensation in lynn
my webpage – mesothelioma case in center line
Also visit my page Mesothelioma Law firm in elkton
Have a look at my site – mesothelioma lawyer New brighton
my homepage – mesothelioma Settlement in south elgin
Feel free to surf to my webpage – mesothelioma litigation In south plainfield
Look at my web site: mesothelioma Compensation in appleton
Also visit my blog; Mesothelioma Litigation In ventura
Look at my webpage – Mesothelioma Litigation Mount Pleasant
my web page – Mesothelioma Settlement Sullivan
my blog post Mesothelioma lawsuit In Medford
My webpage :: mesothelioma compensation in meadows place
Also visit my website mesothelioma claim in hatboro
Feel free to surf to my website – Port orange mesothelioma claim
Feel free to visit my blog post Strasburg mesothelioma settlement
Hurrah! After all I got a web site from where I know how to truck Accident settlement in Brunswick fact get useful information concerning my study
My web site mesothelioma Litigation in tukwila
my page – Point Pleasant Beach Mesothelioma Litigation
Look at my web-site … Mesothelioma litigation yelm
my homepage … mesothelioma lawyer In macclenny
Check out my page – la Palma Mesothelioma Lawyer
Appreciate this post. Will try it out.
my web-site … settlements
my web blog Mesothelioma law firm in gilroy
Have a look at my page :: mesothelioma settlement
My homepage :: mesothelioma Lawyer In wetumpka
My web site – Mesothelioma Law Firm Henderson
Hey just preferred to provide you with a quick heads up. The text inside your post appear to be functioning off the display screen in Chrome. I’m undecided if this is a format issue or a thing to do with World-wide-web browser compatibility but I thought I’d publish to let you already know. The layout glance great however! Hope you receive the challenge solved soon. Thanks
Outstanding weblog post. I Certainly appreciate This website. Thanks!
Hello globalethnographic.com webmaster, Keep sharing your knowledge!
Hi globalethnographic.com admin, You always provide clear explanations and step-by-step instructions.
Dear globalethnographic.com webmaster, Your posts are always thought-provoking and inspiring.
Hi globalethnographic.com administrator, Your posts are always well-cited and reliable.
To the globalethnographic.com admin, You always provide practical solutions and recommendations.
Dear globalethnographic.com webmaster, Your posts are always interesting.
Hi globalethnographic.com owner, Good work!
To the globalethnographic.com owner, Your posts are always well-supported by research and data.
To the globalethnographic.com webmaster, Your posts are always well organized and easy to understand.
Nice post. I learn something totally new and challenging on websites
naturally like your web site however you need to take a look at the spelling on several of your posts. A number of them are rife with spelling problems and I find it very bothersome to tell the truth on the other hand I will surely come again again.
Hello globalethnographic.com webmaster, Nice post!
Hello globalethnographic.com owner, Thanks for the comprehensive post!
I very delighted to find this internet site on bing, just what I was searching for as well saved to fav
To the globalethnographic.com webmaster, Your posts are always well-received and appreciated.
Hi globalethnographic.com administrator, Your posts are always well-timed and relevant.
Dear globalethnographic.com webmaster, Your posts are always well presented.
Good post. I am dealing with some of these issues as well..
To the globalethnographic.com webmaster, You always provide clear explanations and definitions.
Hello globalethnographic.com webmaster, Keep the good content coming!
Hello globalethnographic.com administrator, You always provide great examples and case studies.
Hi globalethnographic.com webmaster, Thanks for the well-researched post!
Awesome! Its genuinely remarkable post, I have got much clear idea regarding from this post
To the globalethnographic.com admin, Your posts are always well organized and easy to understand.
Dear globalethnographic.com owner, Well done!